Reverend and the Cynic

Is it a game show or a commentary show?

On the right hand side we have or in house reverend. On the left side we have a cynical atheist college professor. In the middle we have our moderator who reads news stories and headlines to our panel. Each man is given 3 minutes to state his opinion according to his beliefs, then each is given 2 more minutes to recant, argue the other's opinion or add to their thoughts and a small audience votes on who gave the better argument, using an A and B button on their seat arm to vote. At the end of each show we announce the winner of that episode and keep a season running tally.